The Bristol-born defender opened the scoring for the Old Lady as they narrowly edged their cross-city rivals 4-3 in a seven-goal thriller on Saturday evening.
The last Englishman to achieve this feat was Gerald Hitchens, who scored twice for Inter Milan during the 1961-62 season across the first and second legs.
Kelly joined Juventus on February 3, 2025, initially on a loan with an obligation to buy. Three months later, the club made the move permanent for €17.5 million, plus performance-based add-ons.
Before moving to Italy, the former England youth international had played for Bournemouth and Newcastle United.
